Medicare vs Medicare Advantage

David Gebhardt • February 23, 2023

When you reach the age for Medicare eligibility, there are many decisions you must make for your insurance choice. Chiefly, whether to sign up with Original Medicare or a Medicare Advantage Plan. But understanding their differences can be quite tricky. On the surface, they may seem like the same thing, but each has significant differences that make a difference to your care and finances.

The choice you make depends on several factors, including your location, your health needs, and your financial situation. Here’s a brief look at the differences and circumstances that may help you make your choice.

What is Original Medicare?

Original Medicare is health insurance offered through the federal government. This insurance is available for those 65 and older and some people with certain disabilities. Original Medicare consists of hospital coverage under Part A and Part B, which covers doctor visits, lab work, and medical equipment. There is also the option to enroll in a Part D prescription drug plan.

When you choose to enroll in Original Medicare, you will have a deductible, copays, and coinsurance , but you can visit any healthcare provider who accepts Medicare, usually without a referral or preapproval. You also have the option to enroll in a Medicare supplement plan that helps to cover out-of-pocket costs of your co-pays and coinsurance. This is especially helpful because Medicare has no spending cap for out-of-pocket expenses.

What is Medicare Advantage?

Medicare Advantage is Medicare offered through private insurance companies. This insurance operates much like private insurance you may have received through your employer. Typically, Medicare Advantage plans offer similar features to Original Medicare which includes Part A hospital coverage and Part B medical coverage in exchange for the monthly premium. This Part B premium must be paid whether you choose Original Medicare or a Medicare Advantage plan. Dental, vision and prescription drug coverage are often included.

Most types of Medicare Advantage Plans operate on a preferred provider organization system, meaning you can only visit healthcare providers who are in-network unless you’d like to pay out-of-pocket costs.

Consider Original Medicare If:

You Plan to Travel

Original Medicare is an excellent choice for those who plan to spend retirement traveling. Because you can visit any healthcare provider that accepts Medicare, you are not required to see your home doctor. Additionally, if you get sick on the road, you can find a doctor nearby.

You Have Pre-Existing Conditions

Medicare will not reject your coverage if you have pre-existing conditions. Though, if you intend to purchase a Medigap plan with a pre-existing condition, you must do so within the first six months of enrollment in Part B, or else you risk losing coverage for your condition. It is always an option to switch back and forth between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage, but if you know you need a Medigap plan and have a pre-existing condition, you should choose Original Medicare.

You Can Afford a Supplement Plan

If you fall ill or get a diagnosis requiring a significant amount of care, you could be on the hook to pay thousands out of pocket from co-pays and coinsurance. Therefore, it is wise to purchase a Medigap supplement plan when you sign up for Original Medicare. If your budget does not allow for this, you might should consider a Medicare Advantage plan.

Consider Medicare Advantage If:

You Live in a Broad-Network Area

Though you cannot see any doctor of your choosing, if you live in a city with a pretty broad network of providers who take your specific Medicare Advantage plan, you shouldn’t find an issue choosing a good doctor or specialist you would like to see. This is a common choice for those who live in larger cities or near medical facilities.

You Don’t Plan on Moving

Similarly, since not all providers take all Medicare Advantage plans, it is best to only choose an Advantage plan if you know you will be in an area with available providers. Therefore, if you live in your forever home (or at least long-term) and have no plans to move any time soon, choosing a Medicare Advantage plan can work in your favor.

You Would Like Additional Coverage

Are you looking for additional coverage, such as dental and vision? Then Medicare Advantage may be your best choice, as these additional coverage options are often included in most available plans. This ensures that all of your coverage comes from the same place rather than having to purchase private insurance or pay out of pocket for these services.

Need Assistance With Enrollment?

Understanding your Medicare options can be quite confusing. It can also be time-consuming to do the research yourself. Every person has different needs, and one plan may be better than another for your specific healthcare circumstances. Let us help you. Our team at Patriot Insurance Brokers is available to walk you through the options and steps of enrollment to ensure that you find the perfect plan for you as a Medicare beneficiary. Call us today to get started.

Picture of an insurance agent and two clients at an office discussing coverage options
May 15, 2025
Discover how to choose the best insurance agency in St. Cloud, MN, to meet your needs. Contact Patriot Insurance to find reliable coverage options.
Money, pile of coins with savings book and paper home, concept | Insurance Agency | St. Cloud, MN
May 14, 2025
Learn how working with Patriot Insurance, a trusted agency in St. Cloud, MN, brings peace of mind. Contact us to schedule your free consultation today.
By David Gebhardt March 17, 2025
Understanding Medicare in Minnesota Medicare is a federal health insurance program designed for individuals aged 65 and older, as well as certain younger individuals with disabilities. While Medicare provides nationwide coverage, Minnesota has unique plan offerings and regulations that can impact your choices. Understanding the different Medicare options and enrollment periods is crucial for securing […]
By David Gebhardt December 6, 2024
Life insurance isn’t just another policy. It can help protect your family’s future. It’s the reassurance that, even in life’s most uncertain moments, your family will be cared for. Whether it’s daily expenses, debts, or big dreams like college, life insurance secures their future when it matters most. However, deciding between term life insurance vs […]
By David Gebhardt November 8, 2024
Riding a motorcycle isn’t just a mode of transportation. Riding is about freedom, adventure, and a lifestyle that’s uniquely yours. But with that lifestyle come risks that need the right insurance coverage. Choosing a generic policy can leave gaps, especially when it comes to protecting custom parts, handling claims, or adjusting for seasonal riding. They […]
By David Gebhardt October 14, 2024
As you approach retirement or become eligible for Medicare, understanding your healthcare options becomes crucial. The process can be overwhelming, especially when faced with the choice between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage Plans. If you’re wondering which plan is best for you—or how to make sense of the different options—you’re not alone. Fortunately, at Patriot […]
By David Gebhardt September 16, 2024
Navigating health insurance can often feel overwhelming and confusing, but at Patriot Insurance Brokers, our goal is to make the process as simple and stress-free as possible. Based in Minnesota, with offices in Elk River and Waite Park, we take pride in offering personalized insurance solutions to meet your specific needs. Whether you’re an individual, […]
By David Gebhardt September 10, 2024
Navigating the complex world of Medicare can be a daunting task for many individuals nearing retirement age or those already eligible. The wide variety of options, coverage plans, and regulations can easily overwhelm even the most informed individuals. That’s where Medicare brokers step in to play a pivotal role, helping beneficiaries find the best coverage […]
By David Gebhardt August 19, 2024
Navigating health insurance can feel overwhelming. With so many options, varying plans, and ever-changing regulations, it’s easy to get lost in the details. That’s where we come in. Based in Elk River and Waite Park, we are here to provide personalized, knowledgeable guidance to help you find the best plan for you and your loved […]
By David Gebhardt August 14, 2024
Thanks to an unusual convergence of market trends, ushered in by the pandemic and followed by other disruptive events, you may see a bigger change to the cost of your home and auto insurance than usual when it comes time to renew your policies this year. Insurance rates are based on what an insurer thinks […]
More Posts